Is ChatGPT Optimization Worth It? The short answer is yes. Recently, while going through one of our client’s GA4 report, a small yet interesting data caught my eyes.
The number of users from ChatGPT was tiny. Just 251 new users amounting to just 0.35 % 0f total traffic. What was interesting was not the traffic share but the way those users behaved. To be more precise, I was fascinated by their engagement rate. They were spending more time on the site:
- ChatGPT: 48.57%
- Google CPC: 39.71%
- Google organic: 34.71%
- Bing organic: 33.92%
- Direct: 20.73%
- LinkedIn paid social: 6.98%
Compared to Google, the traffic ChatGPT sent was insignificant. But the users it send were far more interested in the offerings on the site. Their engagement rate was the highest. In other words, ChatGPT send serious users.
To put it into perspective, if we consider Google as a firehose, ChatGPT is still just a garden tap. But people coming from that tiny garden tap shows intent and interest in their pursuit unlike your average web reader.
Table of Contents
ChatGPT Optimization Starts With a Different Kind of Visitor
Consider the typical Google surfer.
He or she types in a search term, reads the results, follows a link to a website, and then arrives at your company’s site. You still have to tell them what you do and who you are.
But with ChatGPT, the visitor may already have done some of the “homework” in arriving there.
They may have told ChatGPT what they were looking for, asked subsequent questions, even narrowed down their options. They may have asked ChatGPT to recommend companies.
And once they’ve done that, they can follow up by clicking on a link to your company’s site.
It’s a fundamental change in the sales process, said Josip Begic, CEO of Lebesgue, an analytics software company. Your job is to persuade the visitor even before they arrive at your site, he noted. That, he believes, is the real-world difference in the value proposition of ChatGPT.
Read: What Is Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) And How Does It Work?
ChatGPT Optimization Is Already Showing Up in Our Leads
One client’s GA4 report is interesting, but it’s hardly a trend.
I went and checked our own pipeline.
In the last two months, Crimson Salt has gotten 15 leads.
3 of them came from ChatGPT
and all of them were high-quality leads. The conversations were different too – these people didn’t need as much education about what GEO is and why they need it. There wasn’t as much back-and-forth.
And one of those three became a paying customer.
That’s a pretty good conversion rate for a channel that only had a sample size of 1. I’m not going to pretend otherwise.
Read: GEO vs SEO – Which One Should You Invest in First?
The Data Behind ChatGPT Optimization Is Pointing in the Same Direction
We’re seeing similar patterns in the data published by other sources.
Seer Interactive looked into the performance of ChatGPT traffic for one domain and saw conversions nearly 16 times higher than for Google organic search (16.4% vs. 1.8%). Overall pages per visit were also better for ChatGPT (2.3x vs. 1.2x).
First Page Sage found similar results for the referral channels across multiple industries, including legal services and higher education, with conversion rates for ChatGPT consistently outperforming Google by several-fold.
While these numbers have little direct relevance to our B2B niche, most of the publicly reported data on AI channel performance comes from the ecommerce space, where a conversion typically means a purchase. For us, it would be a qualified lead, a booked discovery session, or a closed deal.
Another important observation is that the traffic coming from AI search is qualitatively different, in that it has intent and typically follows a specific question.
Finally, there’s the volume – Semrush’s data shows that ChatGPT referral traffic grew 206% year over year for the period between January 2025 and January 2026.
However, the absolute contribution of ChatGPT to date remains low – for the majority of sites, it’s still in the single digits.
ChatGPT Optimization Has a Problem Most People Miss
Here’s the catch.
You don’t get those visitors simply because ChatGPT exists.
The model needs to know that your brand exists in the first place.
It also needs to have enough information about your company to understand what it does.
If your website and other third-party platforms provide conflicting information, your brand positioning is unclear, and there is little information about your company elsewhere, the model will do what it can to fulfill the request.
It can recommend another company. You will never see those lost visitors in GA4. That’s the interesting thing about optimizing for ChatGPT.
With traditional search, you can see the impression, the position, and eventually the click. With AI recommendations, the lost opportunity can happen before your brand is even considered.
ChatGPT visitors arrive with their minds made up.
One client’s GA4 data, plus our own two-month pipeline. Small channel, serious buyers.
So, Is ChatGPT Optimization Worth It?
For everyone? No.
If you’re selling something people buy in five minutes, the economics may look very different.
But for B2B services, consulting, SaaS, anything with a consideration selling process – I think we can agree the water’s getting pretty warm.
ChatGPT is not going to replace Google in the near future. The majority of your traffic is still likely flowing to Google.
The interesting question is what happens to the small percentage of people who start their research somewhere else. Those visitors may be fewer, but they know what they want. They intent to get things done.
The channel is small today. The intent may not be.
And the brands that dominate these conversations are going to have significant AI search share when generative engines starts being a bigger part of the buying process.
The garden tap remains a trickle. I’d rather have it turned on than realize in two years that my competition did.
Sources
2 Comments